Official source Data mirrored from Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Open Payments · General Payments · as published 2026-01-23 View official record Methodology

Covered recipient · General Payments record

JENNIFER D HOLMAN

Allopathic & Osteopathic Physicians Dermatology

NPI
1447354626
CMS profile
201421
Location
TYLER, TX

General Payments · PY2018–2024

$648,198.72

  • Reported across 1,234 records
  • CMS publication 2026-01-23

Latest program year · PY2024

$83,448.26

166 records · 0 disputed

Financial relationships do not necessarily indicate an improper relationship; the data is open to interpretation.

How these totals are calculated
  • The total is the sum of the General Payments records CMS published for the labeled program year(s), exactly as published. Nothing is estimated, weighted, or combined across categories.
  • General Payments only. Research and Ownership/Investment are separate datasets and are never summed with these figures; amounts are kept separate per program year.
  • Featured-page threshold (a presentation gate, not a judgment): records>=3 OR total>=100 (all years).
  • Methodology & Data — sourcing, labeling, and limitations.

By nature of payment

PY2024 · sorted by reported total

By paying entity

PY2024 · sorted by reported total

By program year

All program years on this page · sorted by year

Program yearAmountRecords
PY2018 $99,766.51 194
PY2019 $156,751.49 300
PY2020 $102,708.03 147
PY2021 $65,232.97 142
PY2022 $85,543.88 160
PY2023 $54,747.58 125
PY2024 $83,448.26 166

Payment records · PY2024 (166)

Sorted by paying entity, then date · as published by CMS

Program year 2024 201820192020202120222023 Record-level detail is published for PY2024; earlier years are summarised in “By program year”.
Paying entity Amount Date Nature of payment Dispute status Published Record ID Source
ABBVIE INC. $12.04 01/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932418 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $15.17 01/11/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932420 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $37.50 01/24/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154790 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $97.30 01/31/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932422 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $22.74 02/01/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932424 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $115.25 02/01/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932426 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $899.74 02/01/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188920 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $1,047.80 02/01/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188922 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $13.08 02/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932428 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $121.94 02/09/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188924 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $52.57 02/16/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932430 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $184.92 02/16/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188926 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $262.38 02/16/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188928 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 02/23/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154792 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $2.09 02/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932432 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $25.35 02/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932434 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 03/01/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154794 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 03/01/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154796 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $106.11 03/01/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932436 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $30.47 03/01/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932438 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $444.28 03/01/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188930 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $559.88 03/01/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188932 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $190.87 03/01/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188934 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $20.82 03/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932440 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $59.99 03/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932442 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $20.82 03/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932444 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $36.01 03/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932446 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $42.00 03/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932448 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $436.21 03/02/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188936 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $5,200.00 03/17/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154798 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $1.00 03/19/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932450 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $11.92 03/19/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932452 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $3,250.00 03/21/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154800 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 03/21/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154802 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $8.45 03/21/2024 Education Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104196368 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $17.31 03/22/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932454 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $10.50 04/04/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932456 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $58.74 04/10/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932458 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $1,203.75 04/10/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188938 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $122.42 04/18/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932460 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 04/20/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154804 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $18.33 04/20/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932462 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $263.84 04/20/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188940 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $12.91 04/23/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932464 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $15.05 04/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932466 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $1.50 04/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932468 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $19.74 05/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932470 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $3,250.00 05/13/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154806 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 05/13/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154808 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $7.00 05/13/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932472 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $17.94 05/18/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932474 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $16.09 05/30/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932476 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $1,549.17 06/14/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154810 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4.26 06/14/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932478 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $16.80 06/18/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932480 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $24.34 06/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932482 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $50.00 07/12/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154812 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $23.91 07/18/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932484 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $15.97 07/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932486 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $5.18 08/07/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932488 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $15.03 08/13/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932490 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $21.69 08/29/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932492 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $9.41 09/04/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932494 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $0.91 09/10/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932496 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $18.46 09/10/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932498 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $14.73 09/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932500 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $121.81 10/03/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932502 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $26.58 10/03/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932504 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $3,155.75 10/03/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188942 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $413.36 10/03/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188944 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $325.86 10/03/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188946 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $15.12 10/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932506 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $24.15 10/16/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932508 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $24.38 10/17/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932510 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $112.44 10/17/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932512 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $301.76 10/17/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188948 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $1,080.77 10/17/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188950 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $514.37 10/17/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188952 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $145.77 10/17/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188954 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $6.83 10/31/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932514 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 11/06/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154814 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 11/06/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154816 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 11/06/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154818 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 11/06/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154820 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $14.63 11/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932516 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $85.40 11/08/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188956 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $171.52 11/08/2024 Travel and Lodging Undisputed 01/23/2026 1104188958 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $15.57 11/14/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932518 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $16.21 12/03/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932520 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $4,550.00 12/09/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154822 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $3,250.00 12/09/2024 Compensation for services other than consulting, including serving as faculty or as a speaker at a venue other than a continuing education program Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103154824 CMS
ABBVIE INC. $3.48 12/20/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1103932522 CMS
Dermavant Sciences, Inc. $19.37 12/19/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1127879914 CMS
E.R. Squibb & Sons, L.L.C. $16.30 02/13/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1101568637 CMS
E.R. Squibb & Sons, L.L.C. $15.94 03/18/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1101568641 CMS
E.R. Squibb & Sons, L.L.C. $21.50 03/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1101568644 CMS
Galderma Laboratories, L.P. $16.59 03/05/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1145304577 CMS
Galderma Laboratories, L.P. $14.07 07/09/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1145304579 CMS
Galderma Laboratories, L.P. $16.39 08/19/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1145304581 CMS
Galderma Laboratories, L.P. $96.67 08/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1145304583 CMS
Galderma Laboratories, L.P. $16.54 09/23/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1145304585 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $10.46 01/10/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772346 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $26.86 01/29/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772348 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $26.86 02/21/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772354 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $29.84 03/11/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772358 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $21.49 04/17/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772372 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $12.04 05/06/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772380 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $15.16 05/17/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772384 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $23.73 06/03/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772386 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $28.21 08/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772406 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $16.71 10/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772420 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $24.30 10/07/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772418 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $25.56 10/21/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772422 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $21.73 11/13/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772432 CMS
GENZYME CORPORATION $24.30 12/02/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1139772438 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $2.36 01/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773543 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $19.27 01/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774702 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $0.05 02/22/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773623 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $3.09 02/22/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773723 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $19.19 02/22/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774539 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $22.24 03/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774136 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $28.44 04/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774609 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $26.66 05/24/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773771 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $28.97 06/14/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774228 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $143.45 06/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774734 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $149.97 06/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773590 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $1,337.50 07/02/2024 Consulting Fee Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774239 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $36.26 07/10/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774212 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $27.81 07/16/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774250 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $21.50 08/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773498 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $28.99 08/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774165 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $23.76 09/24/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773873 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $23.32 10/22/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078773527 CMS
Janssen Biotech, Inc. $41.49 12/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1078774326 CMS
Kerecis Limited $38.73 02/14/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1120094911 CMS
LEO Pharma Inc. $26.15 04/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1152634725 CMS
LEO Pharma Inc. $28.87 05/23/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1152634727 CMS
Lilly USA, LLC $17.37 01/11/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1135063023 CMS
Lilly USA, LLC $19.00 02/07/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1135043318 CMS
Lilly USA, LLC $19.78 10/23/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1135058296 CMS
PFIZER INC. $16.29 03/06/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1131253032 CMS
PFIZER INC. $102.42 05/30/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1131681241 CMS
PFIZER INC. $3.71 09/27/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1132067599 CMS
PFIZER INC. $10.27 10/28/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1132090749 CMS
PFIZER INC. $10.19 11/18/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1131010010 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $24.28 02/14/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070879 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $27.92 03/13/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070881 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $29.55 04/09/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070883 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $28.11 04/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070885 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $33.71 05/23/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070887 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $15.96 08/13/2024 Education Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070889 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $25.34 08/28/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070891 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $26.06 09/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070893 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $37.00 11/06/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070895 CMS
Regeneron Healthcare Solutions, Inc. $13.32 12/09/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1114070897 CMS
REVANCE THERAPEUTICS, INC. $87.95 01/30/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1147920268 CMS
REVANCE THERAPEUTICS, INC. $82.52 05/08/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1147920270 CMS
Smith+Nephew, Inc. $15.17 03/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1149605764 CMS
SUN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIES INC. $22.39 01/23/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1152159212 CMS
SUN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIES INC. $22.49 02/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1152159214 CMS
SUN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIES INC. $13.24 08/15/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1152159216 CMS
SUN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIES INC. $31.40 11/26/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1152159210 CMS
UCB, Inc. $18.19 01/25/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1143283174 CMS
UCB, Inc. $23.90 07/11/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1143283179 CMS
UCB, Inc. $26.79 10/21/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1143283183 CMS
UCB, Inc. $15.81 12/11/2024 Food and Beverage Undisputed 01/23/2026 1143283187 CMS

Source & provenance

Dataset
CMS Open Payments — General Payments
Publisher of source data
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
CMS publication date
2026-01-23
Program years on this page
2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024
Source files
Dataset page · Bulk file · PY2018 , PY2019 , PY2020 , PY2021 , PY2022 , PY2023 , PY2024
Generated from
OP_DTL_GNRL_PGYR2024_P01232026_01102026.csv

One page per canonical provider; split Profile_IDs are merged via Associated_Covered_Recipient_Profile_ID_1/_2 from the Covered Recipient Profile Supplement.

Corrections to the substance of a record route to CMS through its review-and-dispute process; errors in how this site mirrors or displays a record route to us. Both paths are described in Methodology & Data.